Most valuable Challenge from the Darkness cards

Updated Oct 5, 2026. Near Mint market prices from recent sales, cross-checked against current listings or a second marketplace. Sealed product and code cards are left out, and an asking price alone never counts.

Top 25 singles

The 25 most valuable cards in Challenge from the Darkness, priciest first

#	No.	Card	Rarity	Last · NM
1	—	S Sabrina's GengarHolo Rare	Holo Rare	$790.00
2	—	B Blaine's CharizardHolo Rare	Holo Rare	$199.43
3	—	K Koga's Ninja TrickUncommon	Uncommon	$121.05
4	—	R Rocket's MewtwoHolo Rare	Holo Rare	$112.76
5	—	I Imakuni?'s DoduoSuper Rare	Super Rare	$81.14
6	—	E Erika's VenusaurHolo Rare	Holo Rare	$68.61
7	—	_ _____'s ChanseyUltra-Rare Uncommon	Ultra-Rare Uncommon	$54.59
8	—	G Giovanni's GyaradosHolo Rare	Holo Rare	$54.20
9	—	B Blaine's MoltresHolo Rare	Holo Rare	$52.08
10	—	B Blaine's ArcanineHolo Rare	Holo Rare	$52.06
11	—	S Sabrina's GazeCommon	Common	$39.01
12	—	R Rocket's ZapdosHolo Rare	Holo Rare	$38.34
13	—	R Rocket's SnorlaxRare	Rare	$35.05
14	—	S Sabrina's AlakazamHolo Rare	Holo Rare	$32.42
15	—	L Lt. Surge's RaichuHolo Rare	Holo Rare	$28.60
16	—	G Giovanni's NidokingHolo Rare	Holo Rare	$28.50
17	—	G Giovanni's PersianHolo Rare	Holo Rare	$27.80
18	—	K Koga's DittoHolo Rare	Holo Rare	$27.64
19	—	G Giovanni's MachampHolo Rare	Holo Rare	$22.74
20	—	S Sabrina's JynxUncommon	Uncommon	$17.77
21	—	K Koga's BeedrillHolo Rare	Holo Rare	$17.49
22	—	S Sabrina's HaunterUncommon	Uncommon	$10.46
23	—	G GiovanniHolo Rare	Holo Rare	$9.27
24	—	E Erika's IvysaurUncommon	Uncommon	$7.63
25	—	G Giovanni's NidoqueenRare	Rare	$7.08

Every card in Challenge from the Darkness →